Home > News > Securities Arbitration

Securities Arbitration


The Daily Journal

Breach Of Fiduciary Duty, Breach of Written Contract

ARBITRATION: $54,105,616.

CASE/NUMBER: Gerald D. Hosier, individually, and as trustee of the Gerald D: Hosier, U/A/D 10/4/99; Brush Creek Capital LLC; Jerry Murdock Jr. v. Citigroup Global Markets Inc. / 09-03297.

COURT/DATE: FINRA/ April 18, 2011.

ARBITRATOR:  Malcolm T. Cleland.

ATTORNEYS: Claimant- Philip M. Aidikoff, Ryan K. Bakhtiari (Aidikoff, Uhl & Bakhtiari, Beverly Hills); Steven B. Caruso (Maddox, Hargett & Caruso, PC, New York,  N,Y.).

Respondent- H. Nicholas Berberian, Patrick G. King, Tina L. Winer (Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg LLP, Chicago, IL.).

FACTS: Gerald Hosier, Brush Creek Capital LLC, and Jerry Murdock entered into arbitration with Citigroup Global Markets Inc., regarding multiple investments in various municipal bond hedge funds.

CLAIMANTS CONTENTIONS:  Hosier, Brush Creek, and Murdock alleged breach of fiduciary duty, breach of contract, constructive fraud, unsuitability, failure to supervise, and respondeat superior .

RESPONDENTS CONTENTIONS:  Citigroup denied the allegations, asserting various affirmative defenses.

DAMAGES: The Net Out of Pocket (NOP) loss in this case as presented to the panel was $26,893,945 and the market adjusted damages were $34,058,948.

RESULT: The panel awarded full market adjusted damages plus $17,000,000 in punitives, $3,000,000 in attorney fees, $33,500 in expert witness fees, $13,168,in court reporter costs, and assessed forum fees of $26,100 against respondents .

ARBITRATORS: Malcom T. Cleland, Marc H. Schtul and Patricia M. Vondra.

« Back to News

The Importance of Selection of Counsel

The retention of an attorney is an important decision made with great care. Please review our web site and examine our experience and credentials.

Contact Us